EPA Publishes Proposed Consent Decrees for Overdue Risk Evaluations

EPA would be required to complete overdue risk evaluations by new deadlines if two proposed consent decrees, announced by EPA on April 26, 2024, are adopted.

Section 6(b)(4)(G) of the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) requires EPA to complete risk evaluations within three years of initiation, with a six-month extension possible.  EPA has missed this 3.5-year deadline for 22 ongoing risk evaluations.  Twenty of these risk evaluations were initiated in December 2019 as a result of amended TSCA’s requirement that EPA designate 20 existing substances as “high-priority,” which automatically initiated risk evaluations.  The other two, which concern the substances DIDP and DINP, were requested by manufacturers.

The proposed consent decrees would resolve two consolidated lawsuits against the agency.  The first, brought by environmental groups, challenges EPA’s failure to complete all 22 overdue risk evaluations; a previous blog post on that case can be found here.  The American Chemistry Council filed the second, which only concerns the two manufacturer-requested risk evaluations.

Under the proposed consent decrees, linked here and here, EPA would be required to complete:

  • Draft risk evaluations for at least seven of the substances, including 1,2-butadiene, by December 31, 2024;
  • Final risk evaluations for DIDP, DINP, TCEP, formaldehyde, and 1,1-dichloroethane by December 31, 2024;
  • Final risk evaluations for seven of the remaining substances, including 1,2-butadiene, by December 31, 2025; and
  • Final risk evaluations for the remaining 10 substances by December 31, 2026.

Under the proposed decrees, EPA could file a motion to extend a deadline if the agency deems it necessary.  The proposed consent decrees also include a provision automatically extending these deadlines if the agency undergoes a lapse in appropriations.

Since the first lawsuit was filed in September 2023, EPA has completed draft risk evaluations for TCEP (more on that here) and formaldehyde.  However, EPA has yet to release draft risk evaluations for any of the other 22 overdue evaluations.

Comments on the proposed consent decrees are due May 28, 2024.