Trade Groups Seek to Expand California Recycling Lawsuit to Challenge Packaging EPR Program

Not long after securing a preliminary injunction against a California law restricting recyclability claims, a group of trade associations is asking a federal court for permission to expand its lawsuit to challenge the state’s extended producer responsibility (EPR) program for packaging.

In an October 8, 2026, motion, the plaintiffs seek leave to add nine claims challenging various provisions of the EPR law—SB 54—as unconstitutionally vague and in violation of the First Amendment, Due Process Clause, and Equal Protection Clause. They also seek to add two state officials as defendants.

The plaintiffs initiated their challenge against California’s “Truth in Recycling” law—SB 343—in March, and secured a preliminary injunction against its enforcement in July.

“The statutory schemes of SB 343 and SB 54 are tightly interwoven—implementation of one informs implementation of the other,” the plaintiffs argue. “By amending the First Amended Complaint, Plaintiffs can pursue more complete relief from laws that place unconstitutional burdens on the products their members sell and seek to continue selling.”

They add that the request is timely because CalRecycle did not promulgate SB 54’s implementing regulations until May, after the lawsuit had been filed.

At least two other lawsuits challenging the EPR program are already pending. One, brought by environmental groups, alleges that the implementing regulations are insufficiently protective of the environment. Another, filed by 17 states and a trade association, raises constitutional arguments against SB 54 similar to those the plaintiffs now seek to assert.

SB 343 Requirements and Injunction

The Truth in Recycling law restricts what products and packaging can carry recyclability claims or the chasing arrows symbol. Its central “60/60 requirement” mandates that the labeled item be collected for recycling in jurisdictions serving at least 60% of Californians and processed by facilities serving at least 60% of recycling programs statewide.

In granting the preliminary injunction, the Southern District of California agreed with the plaintiffs that several provisions of SB 343 were likely to be unconstitutionally vague. These included terms such as “routinely becomes feedstock,” “consistent with the . . . Basel Convention,” “ensure[s]” and “prevent[s] . . . recyclability,” and an unclear reference to industry guidance.

Although the court found that these provisions were severable, it concluded that the law as a whole should be enjoined on First Amendment grounds. The court determined that California had likely failed to demonstrate that SB 343 advanced its asserted interests in improving recycling rates and reducing consumer confusion.

The court reasoned that California had not shown that businesses would redesign their products to meet the law’s requirements rather than simply remove recyclability claims. It also preliminarily concluded that SB 343 would leave consumers with less information about recyclability than they had before.

Proposed New Claims Against SB 54

In seeking leave to amend their complaint, the plaintiffs emphasize the similarities between their existing challenge to SB 343 and their proposed claims against SB 54.

“As already raised in this case, SB 343 uses ambiguous provisions to define the word ‘recyclable,’ and SB 54 incorporates that definition wholesale,” they argue. They contend that other provisions of SB 54 use terminology similar to language the court preliminarily found unconstitutionally vague in SB 343. They also argue that SB 54 imposes commercial speech restrictions that “overlap with those raised” in their original complaint.

The plaintiffs further invoke the need for complete relief and logistical challenges as reason to address both statutes simultaneously, arguing that both laws require updating design, materials, and labels on products and packaging.

The proposed amended complaint would specifically challenge the following provisions of SB 54:

  • Requirements that products and packaging be “recyclable” as unconstitutionally vague;
  • Requirements that certain products and packaging be recycled at incrementally increasing rates as unconstitutionally vague;
  • The meaning of “covered material categories” as unconstitutionally vague;
  • Source reduction requirements based on what is “nonrecyclable” or “less likely to be recycled” as unconstitutionally vague;
  • Recycling target rates as unconstitutionally vague;
  • Provisions governing whether products and packaging are “recyclable” or recycled at a specific rate as depriving the plaintiffs of property without due process;
  • Restrictions on how fees may be communicated to consumers on receipts or invoices as violating the First Amendment;
  • Financial obligations imposed on producers as violating the Equal Protection Clause and Due Process Clause; and
  • Eco-modulated fees “set by a private entity without sufficient government review” as violating the Due Process Clause.

The case is Cal. League of Food Producers v. Bonta, No. 3:26-cv-1675 (S.D. Cal.), filed March 17, 2026.

The ongoing challenges to the EPR program are Nat. Res. Def. Council v. Dep’t of Res. Recycling & Recovery, No. CPF-26-519769 (Cal. Super. Ct. S.F. Cnty. 2026), and State v. Heller, No. 2:26-cv-02214 (E.D. Cal. 2026).