EPA’s 2025 FIFRA Enforcement Trends

/in , ,

EPA has maintained a surprisingly aggressive enforcement posture under the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA) in 2025, even as broader deregulatory and budget-cutting initiatives move forward.  Data from the first part of the year suggest that civil enforcement remains vigorous across multiple sectors and may be exceeding levels seen in previous years.

Key Enforcement Activity

Increased Volume of Cases:  EPA’s Enforcement and Compliance History Online (ECHO) database indicates that 84 FIFRA administrative enforcement cases with civil penalties were opened from February through July 2025.  This represents a notable increase compared to the same period in 2024 and 2023, when approximately 59 and 51 cases were issued, respectively.

Rising Penalties:  EPA’s enforcement in 2025 has produced some of the largest FIFRA settlements on record.  In May, Costco Wholesale Corp. agreed to a $3.07 million settlement for selling unregistered antimicrobial gloves and misbranded air filters, failing to file import notices, and violating a stop‑sale order.  As part of the same enforcement action, Winix America settled for more than $1 million.  A third seven-figure settlement was reached with Stepan Co. for selling or distributing a misbranded pesticide.

Notices of Refusal of Admission:  EPA Region 8 has been actively monitoring pesticide imports along the northern border.  EPA’s administrative enforcement dockets webpage indicates that nearly 50 notices of refusal of admission have been issued in 2025 so far.

FIFRA Expedited Settlement Agreement Pilot Program

A significant number of civil penalties have been assessed through EPA’s Expedited Settlement Agreement (ESA) Pilot Program under FIFRA, launched in January 2025.  The program targets minor, easily correctible violations and provides discounted, non-negotiable settlements, in lieu of formal enforcement.  The pilot program is intended to streamline enforcement while prioritizing resource efficiency and deterrence.

This pilot program will remain available for 36 months from its approval date, with evaluation of its effectiveness slated after 30 months.  ESA penalties have generally ranged from several hundred to several thousand dollars.

Implications for Regulated Entities
  • Enforcement focus remains strong on labeling, registration, import compliance, and antimicrobial products.
  • The ESA Pilot Program may allow expedited resolution but applies only to specific, low-severity violations.
  • Companies should continue to operate under the assumption that enforcement remains robust.
Practical Steps

To manage enforcement risk:

  • Review labeling, registration status, and marketing claims for all pesticide and antimicrobial products.
  • Confirm compliance with import documentation like notices of arrival and relevant filings.
  • Strengthen supplier and private-label compliance monitoring.
  • Conduct a proactive self‑audit under EPA’s Audit Policy, especially if potential minor violations are identified.
  • Evaluate whether any matters may qualify for the FIFRA ESA Pilot Program.
Final Thought

Despite changes in the regulatory landscape, 2025 shows that EPA’s FIFRA enforcement remains serious.  Taking preemptive steps can provide meaningful protection and potentially reduce enforcement exposure.